The Phenomenon of Interethnic Tolerance in Bukovyna (1861-1914): the History of the Bukovynian Jews

Authors

DOI::

https://doi.org/10.31861/hj2017.46.67-75

Abstract

The article analyzes the phenomenon of interethnic tolerance in Bukovyna during the period of 1861-1914 on the example from the history of the Bukovynian Jews. The importance of the concept of «Bukovynism», by which modern scholars consider the phenomenon of interethnic and interconfessional tolerance in Bukovyna, is mentioned. It is proved that mutual understanding in the political and socio-cultural space of Bukovyna was achieved due to the efforts of the Austrian administration during 1861-1914. Among the factors contributing to the establishment of political consensus here, the author names such as the reform of the political system of the Austrian empire in the 1960s of the XIXth century, high intensity of the ethno-cultural communications in Bukovyna (interlingual interference) and the migration policy of the central authorities, as a result of which there was formed the German-Jewish political symbiosis with the «new socio-economic ideology»of the «Middle European economic people».

The Jews, who in the second half of the XIXth century reached a marked level of political influence on the processes of socio-economic life of Bukovyna, at the beginning of the XXth century, found themselves, according to the author, in a unique situation, in which they almost did not feel the manifestations of the policy of anti-Semitism, which became noticeable in other provinces of Austria-Hungary, as well as in Vienna; the Bukovyna Jews proved to be more bearers of imperial loyalty than the Germans themselves; they managed to preserve their traditional culture, focused, first of all, in shtetls (the Jewish towns) and at the same time remained a “demographic reserve” in the production of the cultural values in Bukovyna.

Instead, during the given historical period the Bukovynian Jews did not avoid the negative phenomena in their political life, which were connected, first of all, with the processes of modernization of the Habsburg Empire (urbanization, nationalism of imperial ethnic groups) and strengthening of the Viennese anti-Semitism at the beginning of the XXth century. The Austrian administration in Bukovyna stubbornly denied the Jews as an independent ethno-group, and in the economic life of the region gradually introduced the principles of segregation of the Jews. But such negative phenomena almost did not affect the situation of the Jews of Bukovyna, which, until the beginning of the World War, remained generally satisfactory, and showed, on the one hand, that the general-imperial economic crisis of the 1870s in Bukovyna did not acquire such sharpness, as in other regions of the country, and on the other hand, that alternatives to tolerant relations in the processes of harmonious development of multinational societies do not exist.

Key words: Bukovynism, tolerance, identity, Jews, Bukovуna

Author Biography

Oleksandr Bezarov, Yuriy Fedkovych Chernivtsi National University

PhD in History, Associate Professor of the Deptartament of New and Modern History

References

I. Burkut, Rol' hreko-katolyts'koyi tserkvy v etnodyferentsiynykh ta etnokonsolidatsiynykh protsesakh na Bukovyni (XVIII – XX st.) [The role of the Greek Catholic Church in ethno-differential and ethno-consolidative processes in Bukovina in XVIII – XIX centuries], in: «Burkut I., Hakman S. Kul'turni marshruty / Vidbir statey», Clui-Napoca, Editura Qual Media, 2009, s. 49-57;
K. Hnydka, Spetsyfika fenomenu «bukovynizm» yak pohranychnoho typu kul'tury [Specificity of the phenomenon of «Bukovynism» as a border type of culture], in: «Pravoslaven boholsovsky fakul'tetet. Velykotyrnovsky unyverstytet «Sv. Sv. Kyryl y Metodyy», at: http: // pbfvt.pravoslavie.bg / index. php; O. Sukhomlynov, Bukovyna yak pohranychchya kul'tur (v konteksti intehratsiynykh protsesiv v Yevropi) [Bukovina as the border of cultures (in the context of integration processes in Europe)], in: «Bliźej siebie. Rumuni I Polacy w Europie. Historia i dzień disiejszy – Mai aproape unii de alţii. Români şi polonozi în Europa. Istorie şi present», Suceava, 2006, s. 69-77;
K. Feleshko, «Bukovyna – miniatyurna Yevropa». Lehendy, metody, diysnist' [«Bukovina is a miniature Europe». Legends, methods, reality], in: «Materialy III Mizhnarodnoyi istoryko-krayeznavchoyi naukovoyi konferentsiyi, prysvyachenoyi 120-richchyu zasnuvannya Chernivets'koho universytetu (29 veresnya – 1 zhovtnya 1995 r., Chernivtsi)», Chernivtsi, Ruta, 1995, s. 179-187.
O. Ohuy, Movna sytuatsiya na Bukovyni v avstriys'kyy period: dynamika krayovykh mov u sotsiolinhvistychnomu aspekti (1774 – 1918 rr.) [The language situation in Bukovina in the Austrian period: the dynamics of regional languages in the sociolinguistic aspect in 1774 – 1918], in: «Naukovyy visnyk Skhidnoyevropeys'koho natsional'noho universytetu im. L. Ukrayinky», 2013, #20, s. 253.
M. Chuchko, Fenomen bukovyns'koyi tolerantnosti u konteksti vzayemyn v kintsi XIV – na pochatku XX stolittya [Phenomenon of Bukovina tolerance in the context of relations in the late fourteenth - early twentieth century], in: «Istorychna panorama: Zbirnyk naukovykh statey ChNU. Spetsial'nist' «Istoriya», Chernivtsi, Ruta, 2007, Vypusk 3, s. 27-29.
Istoriya rozvytku orhaniv vlady na terytoriyi Chernivets'koyi oblasti [History of development of the authorities on the territory of the Chernivtsi region], O. Dobrzhans'kyy, A. Kruhlashov, M. Yarmystyy, Chernivtsi, Bukrek, 2014, s. 212.
V. Botushans'kyy, H. Chayka, Sklad studentiv Chernivets'koho universytetu v period Avstro-Uhorshchyny (1875-1918 rr.) [Composition of the students of the Chernivtsi University during the Austro-Hungarian period (1875-1918)], in: «Materialy III Mizhnarodnoyi istoryko-krayeznavchoyi naukovoyi konferentsiyi, prysvyachenoyi 120-richchyu zasnuvannya Chernivets'koho universytetu (29 veresnya – 1 zhovtnya 1995 r., Chernivtsi), Chernivtsi, Ruta, 1995, c. 138.
S. Moshenskyy, Fynansovye tsentry Ukrayny y rynok tsennykh bumah yndustryal'noy epokhy [Financial centers of Ukraine and the market of securities of the industrial era], London, Xlibris, 2014, s. 163-192.
Y. Monolatyy, Evrey y nemtsy – zhytely sel'skokhozyaystvennykh kolonyy Halytsyy (konets XVIII – XX vv.) [Jews and Germans ‒ residents of the agricultural colonies of Galicia (late XVIII - early XX centuries)], in: «Materyaly Vos'moy ezhehodnoy mezhdunarodnoy mezhdystsyplynarnoy konferentsyy po yudayke. Ch. 1», Moskva, Probel-2000, 2002, s. 55-69.
O. Kottsiyan, Znachennya universytetu dlya «Chernivets'koho mifu» / Per. z nim. P. Rykhla [The significance of the university for the "Chernivtsi myth"], in: «Materialy III Mizhnarodnoyi istoryko-krayeznavchoyi naukovoyi konferentsiyi, prysvyachenoyi 120-richchyu zasnuvannya Chernivets'koho universytetu (29 veresnya – 1 zhovtnya 1995 r., Chernivtsi)», Chernivtsi, Ruta, 1995. s. 195.
V. Fysanov, Problema bezopasnosty v uslovyyakh podvyzhnykh heopolytycheskykh tochek: sluchay s Bukovynoy [The problem of security in the context of mobile geopolitical points: the case of Bukovina], in: «Pohranychnye rayony na post·sovet·skom prostranstve: netradytsyonnye aspekty bezopasnosty / Materyaly semynara / Fond Dzhona D. y Katryn T. Makarturov, Chernovtsy, oktyabr' 1996», Kyev, Fenyks, 1997, s. 82-89.
Ynostrannoe obozrenye [Foreign Review], in: «Knyzhky Voskhoda. Zhurnal uchёno-lyteraturnyy y polytycheskyy», 1904, May, s. 270.
F. Kheyman, Povernennya pam"yati: Storinky yevreys'koyi istoriyi Chernivtsiv [Return to memory: Pages of the Jewish history of Chernivtsi], Kyyiv, Dukh i Litera, 2016, s. 34 ‒ 35.
L. Schmelzer. Geschichte des Zionismus in der Bukowina [History of Zionism in Bukovina], in: Hugo Gold (Hg.), Geschichte der Juden in der Bukowina, Bd. I, Tel Aviv, 1958, p. 91.
A. Bezarov, Yz ystoryy evreev na Bukovyne (XIX-XX vv.) [From the history of Jews in Bukovina (XIX ‒ XX centuries)], in: «Yevreys'ka istoriya ta kul'tura v Ukrayini. Materialy konferentsiyi, Kyyiv, 22 ‒ 23 lystopada 1993 r.», Kyyiv, Asotsiatsiya yudayiky Ukrayiny, 1994, s. 22-23.
I. Hol'tser, Prosvita, asymilyatsiya ta nova identychnist': yevreys'ka elita na Halychyni [Enlightenment, Assimilation and New Identity: The Jewish Elite in Galicia], in: «Polin. Vybrani statti / Per. z anhl.», Kyyiv, Dukh i Litera, 2011, s. 79.
Zapysky [Notes], in: «Bukovyna. Orhan ukrayins'koyi postupovoyi partiyi na Bukovyni», 1909, 28 sichnya, s. 2.
Vovky v ovechiy shkuri [Wolves in Sheepskin], in: «Bukovyna. Orhan ukrayins'koyi postupovoyi partiyi na Bukovyni», 1909, 22 sichnya, s. 1-2.
Soymova reforma vyborcha [Parliamentary electoral reform], in: «Bukovyna. Orhan ukrayins'koyi postupovoyi partiyi na Bukovyni», 1909, 12 zhovtnya, s. 1.
Donesennya Dyrektsiyi politsiyi pro perebih yevreys'kykh narodnykh zboriv, 7 travnya 1910 r. [Report of the Police Board on the course of the Jewish People's Assembly, May 7, 1910], in: «Yevreys'ke naselennya ta rozvytok yevreys'koho natsional'noho rukhu na Bukovyni v ostanniy chverti XVIII – na pochatku XX st.: Zbirnyk dokumentiv i materialiv / Upor. O. V. Dobrzhans'kyy, M. P. Kushnir, M. D. Nykyrsa», Chernivtsi, Nashi knyhy, 2007, s. 312.
Iz statti «Shkil'ni spravy» u hazeti «Die Volkswehr», 18 zhovtnya 1910 r. [From the article "School Affairs" in the newspaper Die Volkswehr, October 18, 1910], in: «Yevreys'ke naselennya ta rozvytok yevreys'koho natsional'noho rukhu na Bukovyni v ostanniy chverti XVIII – na pochatku XX st.: Zbirnyk dokumentiv i materialiv / Upor. O. V. Dobrzhans'kyy, M. P. Kushnir, M. D. Nykyrsa», Chernivtsi, Nashi knyhy, 2007, s. 329.
Iz statti «Shkil'ni spravy» u hazeti «Die Volkswehr», 18 zhovtnya 1910 r., s. 331-332.
V. Botushans'kyy, Orhanizatsiya narodnoho shkil'nytstva na Bukovyni (70-ti rr.. XIX – pochatok XX st.) [Organization of folk schooling in Bukovina (70 s. XIX ‒ beginning of the twentieth century)], in: «XI Bukovyns'ka mizhnarodna istoryko-krayeznavcha konferentsiya prysvyachena 100-richchyu Ukrayins'koyi natsional'noyi revolyutsiyi. Tezy dopovidey, Chernivtsi, 20 ‒ 21 zhovtnya 2017 r.», Chernivtsi, Tekhnodruk, 2017, s. 22.
Za hranytsey [Abroad], in: «Vestnyk Obshchestva rasprostranenyya prosveshchenyya mezhdu evreyamy v Rossyy», 1912, #16, s. 126.
Napad na prava chernovets'kykh horozhan [Assault on the rights of Chernivtsi citizens], in: «Borba. Ukrayins'kyy sotsial-demokratychnyy robitnychyy zhurnal», 1911, 15 hrudnya, s. 1-2.
Zamitka «Vshanuvannya deputata doktora Shtraukhera» z hazety «Die Volkswehr», 12 serpenya 1910 r. [Note «Honoring the Deputy of Dr. Strauheer» from the newspaper Die Volkswehr, August 12, 1910], in: «Yevreys'ke naselennya ta rozvytok yevreys'koho natsional'noho rukhu na Bukovyni v ostanniy chverti XVIII – na pochatku XX st..: Zbirnyk dokumentiv i materialiv / Upor. O. V. Dobrzhans'kyy, M. P. Kushnir, M. D. Nykyrsa», Chernivtsi, Nashi knyhy, 2007, s. 323.
A. Kastelyanskyy, Obshchaya statystyka / Avstryya [Common statistics / Austria], in: «Evreyskaya entsyklopedyya. Svod znanyy o evreystve y eho kul'ture v proshlom y nastoyashchem», Tom 1, SPb, Obshchestvo dlya nauchnykh evreyskykh yzdanyy, Brok·hauz-Efron, s. 343.
E. Voloshchuk, Fenomen evreyskoy Ukrayny y eho lyteraturnye proektsyy [The phenomenon of Jewish Ukraine and its literary projections], in: “Collegium”. Mezhdunarodnyy nauchno-khudozhestvennyy zhurnal», 2017, #27, s. 163.
Iz vystupu deputata Benno Shtraukhera z pytannya vyborchoyi reformy na zasidanni Avstriys'koyi palaty posliv 13 bereznya 1906 roku, 13 bereznya 1906 r. [From the speech of deputy Benno Strauheer on the question of electoral reform at the Austrian Ambassadorial meeting March 13, 1906, March 13, 1906], in: «Yevreys'ke naselennya ta rozvytok yevreys'koho natsional'noho rukhu na Bukovyni v ostanniy chverti XVIII – na pochatku XX st.: Zbirnyk dokumentiv i materialiv / Upor. O. V. Dobrzhans'kyy, M. P. Kushnir, M. D. Nykyrsa», Chernivtsi, Nashi knyhy, 2007, s. 229 ‒ 232.
Sh. Sen'obos, Polytycheskaya ystoryya sovremennoy Evropy [Political history of modern Europe], Tom 2, SPb, Tovaryshchestvo «Znanye», 1903, s. 475 ‒ 478.
Shmy, Ynostrannoe obozrenye [Foreign Review], in: «Knyzhky Voskhoda. Zhurnal uchёno-lyteraturnyy y polytycheskyy», 1904, Yyul', s. 248.
M., Evrey v Halytsyy [Jews in Galicia], in: «Knyzhky Voskhoda. Zhurnal uchёno-lyteraturnyy y polytycheskyy», 1903, Avhust, s. 122.

Published

2017-12-20

How to Cite

Bezarov, O. (2017). The Phenomenon of Interethnic Tolerance in Bukovyna (1861-1914): the History of the Bukovynian Jews. History Journal of Yuriy Fedkovych Chernivtsi National University, (46), 67-75. https://doi.org/10.31861/hj2017.46.67-75